Skip to content
Core Commercial Roofing

Commercial roofing article

Silicone vs Acrylic Roof Coating in Texas: Which One Survives West Texas?

Published November 19, 2026

For most flat commercial roofs in Texas, silicone is the safer coating because it tolerates ponding water that breaks acrylic down. Acrylic still makes sense on sloped metal and low-slope roofs that drain completely.

Silicone and acrylic roof coatings compared on a commercial metal roof in Texas

For most flat commercial roofs in Texas, silicone is the safer coating because it tolerates ponding water that breaks acrylic down. Acrylic still makes sense on sloped metal roofs and low-slope roofs that drain completely, where upfront cost matters most.

Most building owners ask me which coating is "better" as if one answer fits every roof. It does not. Your roof's slope, drainage, existing membrane and the West Texas weather decide the right chemistry. Below is how I walk owners through that decision, one question at a time.

Quick answer for West Texas owners

  • Water stands on your roof more than 48 hours after rain: choose silicone.
  • Sloped metal roof or a low-slope roof that drains fully: acrylic is a sound, lower-cost option.
  • Roof already coated in silicone: your next coat must be silicone.
  • Wet insulation or widespread hail damage: neither coating will fix it. Repair or replace first.

What is the actual difference between silicone and acrylic roof coatings?

Acrylic is a water-based latex coating that cures as its water evaporates. Silicone is a solvent-based coating that cures by reacting with moisture in the air, and it stays unaffected when water sits on it.

The two chemistries are even written to different industry standards. ASTM D6083 covers liquid-applied, water-dispersed acrylic latex roof coatings. ASTM D6694 covers silicone coatings whose main polymer is more than 95% silicone, and it was written around silicone's original job of protecting spray foam roofing in Texas from UV damage.

Those chemistry differences drive everything else: how each coating handles standing water, how fast it cures in dry air, how much dirt it holds and what can go on top of it later.

Factor Silicone Acrylic
Base chemistry Solvent-based, moisture-cured Water-based acrylic latex
Ponding water Tolerates standing water Softens and breaks down; needs full drainage
Best fit Flat and low-slope TPO, EPDM, mod bit, SPF Sloped metal and well-drained low-slope roofs
Typical service life 15 to 20 years at full thickness 10 to 15 years
Material cost Roughly 20% to 30% higher Lower
Build per pass Up to about 40 mils in one pass Several thinner coats
Minimum application temperature 35°F and rising 50°F and rising
Cure in dry West Texas air Slower, since it needs humidity Faster, since water evaporates quickly
Dust and dirt Holds dirt; needs periodic washing Stays cleaner, but its surface slowly erodes
Future recoat Silicone only Acrylic, or silicone after an adhesion test
Color options Limited: white, gray, tan Wide range

Why does West Texas weather change the usual advice?

Most silicone vs acrylic comparisons are written for humid climates, where silicone wins almost every category. West Texas is semi-arid, so dry air helps acrylic cure and slows silicone, while hail, wind and blowing dust add risks most guides never mention.

Lubbock averages about 18.3 inches of precipitation a year and racks up roughly 1,950 cooling degree days, according to the National Weather Service's 1991 to 2020 normals. Long, hot summers make reflectivity valuable. Low humidity changes how each coating cures on the roof.

The dry climate does not erase silicone's main advantage, though. When rain does come here, it often arrives fast and hard in spring and summer storms. A flat roof with clogged scuppers or low spots can hold water for days after a single cell passes through. Before you pick a coating, look honestly at commercial roof drainage failures on your own building.

Which coating handles ponding water on flat roofs?

Silicone handles ponding water; acrylic does not. Because acrylic is water-based, standing water softens it, and over time it can blister, lose adhesion and peel away from the roof.

The roofing industry generally defines ponding as water still standing 48 hours after rain. CertainTeed's own coating guidance steers acrylic toward sloped metal roofs and roofs with positive drainage, and silicone toward flat roofs, low-slope roofs and areas prone to ponding.

Two cautions apply. First, silicone protects the surface, but it does not fix the reason water sits there. If the deck sags or drains are undersized, the membrane underneath still carries that load. Second, if ponding has already soaked the insulation, no coating is the right answer. In that case, compare roof coating vs full replacement before spending money on material.

How do silicone and acrylic coatings hold up to Lubbock hail?

Neither silicone nor acrylic makes a roof hail-proof. How a coated roof survives a hailstorm depends mostly on what sits under the coating: a firm, dry substrate and a properly built coating thickness matter more than the chemistry on top.

Hail is the defining roof risk on the South Plains. The NOAA Storm Prediction Center's Lubbock severe weather climatology shows the Lubbock radar area averaged about 325 hail reports and 50 hail days per year from 1980 to 2006. Any coating you choose here has to be planned around hail.

Here is what actually protects you:

  • Dry insulation. Wet insulation crushes under impact, and the coating fractures with it. An infrared thermal roof inspection finds trapped moisture before you coat.
  • Full coating thickness. Thin coatings bruise through faster. Get the target dry mils in writing.
  • Documented damage before coating. A fresh coating can hide hail evidence your insurance adjuster needs. Photograph and report storm damage first.
  • Tested assemblies. Hail ratings belong to complete roof systems, not a bucket of coating. Ask whether the system carries a listing such as FM Global approved roofing.

Does West Texas dust make silicone lose its reflectivity?

Yes. Silicone tends to hold surface dirt, so a silicone roof in dusty West Texas will lose some of its bright-white reflectivity until it is washed. Acrylic stays cleaner, but its surface slowly erodes, which thins the coating over time.

Reflectivity is where much of a coating's energy value comes from. The U.S. Department of Energy's guide to cool roofs says a cool roof can cut a single-story building's annual air-conditioning energy use by up to 15% in hot climates. The same guide warns that many roofs become less reflective with age, so savings should be estimated from long-term reflectance, not the brand-new number.

For a silicone roof, plan a gentle wash every few years, especially after windy planting and harvest seasons. For an acrylic roof, plan to check film thickness, since erosion slowly uses up the coating. Either way, dust works on your roof alongside heat and sun, which is why Texas UV exposure and reflectivity upkeep belong in the same maintenance plan.

How much does each coating cost, and which is cheaper long term?

Silicone material usually costs about 20% to 30% more than acrylic. The installed gap is often smaller, because silicone can reach full thickness in fewer passes and with fewer trips back to the roof.

A MuleHide territory manager quoted in a 2026 Roofers Coffee Shop discussion put silicone at that 20% to 30% premium and noted silicone can build up to about 40 mils in a single pass. Acrylic applied too heavily in one coat can skin over and trap moisture, so it typically goes down in multiple lighter coats. Every extra coat means extra labor, extra cure time and another day exposed to West Texas wind.

For a sound commercial roof, a full coating system typically runs in the range of $4 to $9 per square foot, depending on prep, repairs and thickness. Long term, compare cost per year of service rather than price per gallon:

  • On a well-drained roof, acrylic's lower price and 10 to 15 year life can be the better value.
  • On a ponding roof, acrylic's lower price is money spent on a coating that fails early.

Fold the recoat cycle into your plan from day one. Our guide on how to budget for commercial roof maintenance shows how to set money aside year by year.

Can you switch from silicone to acrylic later?

No. Once a roof is coated in silicone, every future recoat needs to be silicone, because almost nothing else bonds reliably to cured silicone. Your first coating choice locks in your next 20 or more years of maintenance.

The reverse direction is more forgiving. Silicone can usually go over a sound, clean acrylic coating once an adhesion test confirms the bond. Manufacturers typically support adhesion testing, and it is worth doing on any recoat, since a failed bond means the new coating peels off in sheets.

The same logic applies to the membrane underneath. Primer and compatibility rules differ by roof type, which is why coating a TPO roof in Texas follows different steps than coating an EPDM roof.

When can you apply silicone and acrylic coatings in Texas?

Acrylic needs temperatures of about 50°F and rising, while silicone can go down at about 35°F and rising. In West Texas, silicone's lower limit gives it a longer working season through late fall and early spring.

Those minimums come from CertainTeed's application guidance, and the reasons matter. Acrylic that freezes before it cures can be permanently damaged, so a cold front arriving overnight can ruin a fresh acrylic coat. Silicone that gets cold after application simply cures more slowly and keeps curing.

Humidity works in the opposite direction for each product. Dry air speeds acrylic's cure and slows silicone's, which is a real advantage for acrylic on a dry Lubbock summer day. Wind is the other West Texas factor. Blowing dust on wet coating weakens the bond, so crews should watch the forecast and stop when gusts pick up.

So which coating should you choose for your building?

Choose silicone if your roof is flat or low-slope, holds water anywhere, or is already coated with silicone. Choose acrylic if your roof is sloped metal or drains completely, and you want the lower upfront cost or a specific color.

Whichever chemistry wins, the coating only performs as well as the roof under it. Start with a moisture survey and drainage check, then match the coating to what you find. For a deeper look at service life by product and thickness, read how long a commercial roof coating lasts.

Frequently asked questions

Is silicone roof coating worth the extra cost in Texas?

On flat or low-slope roofs that hold water, yes, because acrylic breaks down under ponding and fails early. On a sloped metal roof that sheds water, acrylic often delivers better value for the money.

Can you coat a roof that has hail damage?

Only after the damage is documented for insurance and repaired, and only if the insulation underneath is dry. Coating over wet or crushed insulation traps the problem and shortens the life of the whole roof.

How often should a coated roof be cleaned in West Texas?

Silicone roofs benefit from a gentle wash every few years, and sooner after heavy dust seasons, to restore reflectivity. Acrylic roofs need less washing but should have their film thickness checked during routine inspections.

Do silicone and acrylic coatings count as cool roofs?

Most white silicone and acrylic coatings are highly reflective and many carry rated reflectance values. Check the product's aged ratings, and see our guide to ENERGY STAR roof certification in Texas for what qualifies.

Conclusion

The silicone vs acrylic decision comes down to what your roof does with water. If water sits anywhere on a flat or low-slope roof, silicone is the coating that will still be protecting it years from now. If your roof is sloped metal or drains completely, acrylic gives you solid protection at a lower upfront cost, and its faster cure suits dry West Texas weather.

Neither coating can save a roof with wet insulation or unrepaired hail damage. Get the roof checked for moisture, fix the drainage, document any storm damage, and then choose the chemistry. Keep in mind that a silicone roof stays silicone at every future recoat, so make that first choice with the next 20 years in mind.

Find out which coating fits your West Texas roof

We survey moisture, check drainage, and test adhesion so you get a straight recommendation on silicone, acrylic, or neither before anyone rolls coating.

Request a roof inspection or call (806) 404-1250.

Next step

Get a condition report before you commit to a system.

Photographs, documented findings, and a written recommendation. Certificate of insurance available before contract.

Zac Ammons, founder of Core Commercial Roofing and Coatings, on a commercial metal roof in West Texas

Written and reviewed by Zac Ammons, Core Commercial Roofing & Coatings.

Commercial roofing field experience across West Texas. Content is reviewed against current NRCA guidance and manufacturer technical data.

Last reviewed November 19, 2026

Call nowRequest inspection